do you have any articles of were it cause damage to the knees. we do ours on the grass and i feel great. but we only get 6 to 7 for 20 yards. and we do 3 -4 set with max rest of 5 mins. i feel the most stress in my quads after i am finish. i feel real fatigue.
When you are doing these frog leaps is “your” objective to get as much height/distance from the jump (push-off) or do you simply treat it as a squat/burpie form of exercise, regardless of how many/how long the jumps take? …I ask b/c depending on your answer, it makes a world of difference on your knees.
You can simply look at any medical journal (Medline or PubMed) that discusses injuries to the knees, there is an abundance of info. out there. When making your queries use terms like, ACL tears and Meniscal Tears (Lateral mostly).
You say that you only get 6-7 leaps for 20 Yds. thats seems about right, but it also depends on your height and how you execute the exercise (explosive or strength)?
You definetly want to use good arm swing, thats for sure, its necessary for body control during landing and while in air. However, if your objective is to get as much distance as possible, I think it is very difficult to get a “soft” landing even when landing on a mat or grass. This will no doubt put a considerable amount of shear force on you knees (as well as other areas, ie, shins, etc). Although, not to sound contradicting, if you have done these drills and feel they work for you, then use that as your guage.
Also, you said “I know if I’m doing 11-12 jumps for 30 yds… NO INDOORS for me”…can you explain?
If frog jumps are so damaging to the knees my whole training group should in theory have their knees destroyed and be injured with the volumes we handle. I think you’re paying too much attention to doctors, they’ll always say everything is dangerous. As long as an athlete has an appropriate strength base and isn’t doing a major screw up technically there should be no problem. We start with unweighted frog jumps at the beginning of our GPP and then build up to 6x8 with 40kg barbell (which we are at right now, this is the peak of the volume), after this, doing them unweighted and with less volume will produce excellent results. Of course, an athlete with weak quads and/or poor quads flexibility shouldn’t think about this one, there it’s a sure recipe for disaster, but with appropriate muscular and tissue strength levels I’ve never seen this cause problems.
I would agree with you aln, however, it isn’t the muscle strenght or imbalance that worries me its more the forces being put on ligaments (cruciates) but most espacially the meniscii, since these are more prone to injury.
It just seems that the risk involved (at times) far outweighs the benefits of frog jumps, especially since you can achieve the same (maybe even better) results by doing other plyos or “single” frog jumps into a large (high-jump) mat.
Also, many times, athletes including myself, because of all the hussle and bussle of everyday life forget to bring to practice the proper equipment or shoes, etc and thats all it takes to cause injury b/c athletes convince themselves that they’ll “make doo” with what they have. They do this or that, and it takes one wrong twist or jump, etc and there goes a ligament…
My take home message would be…if they have worked for you great, but don’t discard or not keep an open mind to other avenues that may achieve the same results with minimal risk.