Certainly a good point.
The only “scientific research” I have come across regarding Mean/Peak activation %'s:
Original Link: http://www.t-nation.com/free_online_article/sports_body_training_performance/advanced_glute_training
And…
Original Link: http://www.elevatingfitness.com/article/i-am-glute-guy-and-here-are-my-secrets-04262010
The winners.
Based on this experiment, here are the top three exercises in terms of mean and peak activity for each muscle part:
Glute Medius.
Mean: Quadruped Hip Circle, Band Standing External Rotation, Barbell Hip Thrust.
Peak: Quadruped Hip Circle, Quadruped Band Donkey Kick, Quadruped Hip Extension.
Upper Glute Maximus.
Mean: Barbell Hip Thrust, Band Skorcher Hip Thrust, Quadruped Hip Circle.
Peak: Quadruped Hip Extension, Barbell Hip Thrust, Bird Dog.
Mid Glute Maximus.
Mean: Band Standing Hip External Rotation, Band Skorcher Hip Thrust, Barbell Hip Thrust.
Peak: Band Standing Hip External Rotation, Band Skorcher Hip Thrust, Cable Standing Hip External Rotation.
Lower Glute Maximus.
Mean: Deadlift, Band Hip Thrust, Band Standing Hip External Rotation.
Peak: Single Leg Hip Thrust, Shoulder Elevated Single Leg Hip Thrust, Deadlift.