Book Reviews

I know some of you have these books -

maybe you could give me a quick guide as to the best/better and not worth it ones from this list please …

Renegade Training for Football - Davies
Science and Practice of Strength Training Zatsiorsky
Supertraining 2003 sixth edition - Siff
Modern Trends in Strength Training - Poliquin
Fundamentals of Special Strength Training in Sport - Verkhoshansky
Program and Organization of Training - Verkhoshansky
Science of Sports Training - Kurz
Secrets of Soviet Sports Fitness and Training - Yessis
Cryotherapy in Sport Injury Management - Knight
Sports Restoration and Massage - Siff & Yessis

Thanks

Gf, DavidW, Xman, Clemson, Richard, CoolCol? anyone?

Supertraining is a great reference but a hard read. i think “Facts and Fallacies” is a little easier read if you are into Dr. Mel Siff.

Thanx Quik

Science and Practice of Strength Training Zatsiorsky

Indept & technical —> excellant reference.

CP didnt follow Clemson’s advice re:length of book. PM me about this :wink:

Thanks GF,
Anyone else got good reccomendations for readings?

Have you read this one Clemson - Cryotherapy in Sport Injury Management - Knight
Any thoughts?

A great book 23…no bs just addresses real questions.

Renegade Training for Football - Davies
Science and Practice of Strength Training Zatsiorsky
Supertraining 2003 sixth edition - Siff
Modern Trends in Strength Training - Poliquin
Fundamentals of Special Strength Training in Sport - Verkhoshansky
Program and Organization of Training - Verkhoshansky
Science of Sports Training - Kurz
Secrets of Soviet Sports Fitness and Training - Yessis
Cryotherapy in Sport Injury Management - Knight
Sports Restoration and Massage - Siff & Yessis

One of these is not like the others. All of the above are fairly information dense texts (except maybe Poliquin’s as well) and are worthwhile additions to most training libraries.

Don’t bother with the Davies book, a whole lot of pictures and little else. He makes some definitions, but it was the most singularly useless book I’ve ever bought on training. Supposedly he goes into a bit more depth on his “extreme sports” training book, but I won’t know, because I won’t buy it.

Shaf

2nd and 3rd I have. 2nd - good, but can take some deep thought to make use of :slight_smile:
3rd - I use it more like a reference book which I refer to now and then, other than that its a doorstop :smiley:
More for understanding the hows and whys I guess. The strength training side of things isnt that practical IMO.

I have read the Yessis book - very old, very general, pretty useless. Seems all Yessis stuff is so basic and pared down. Well that’s my impression.

The first Yuri book is suposed to be decent, but if you ahve read my preview post of iot, it is pretty technical mixed with with odd Russian translation prose.

Training of the Weightlifter by RA Roman may interest you.
I hope to pick it up soon.

from Kenny Croxdale - a preview of sorts

Fundamentals of Special Strength Training in Sports/Verkhoshansky

Page 56 The EXPLOSIVE-ISOMETRIC type of muscular tension is inherent to movements in which significant resistance is overcome (for example, snatch or jerking…throwing a heavy projectile). A basic peculiarity of these movements is the necessity to develop a significant working-force: the MAXIMAL is achieved, advantageously, AT THE END OF THE MOVEMENT.

The EXPLOSIVE-BALLISTIC type of muscular tension is characteristic of movements in which maximal force is applied to a relatively small resistance (for example, the shot put, javelin…). Here the motive force reaches maximum quickly AT THE BEGINNING and MIDDLE ranges of the movement, then begins to diminish. …As the resistance increases, this type of muscular tension switches to EXPLOSIVE-Ballistic.

The EXPLOSIVE-REATIVE-BALLISTIC type of muscular tension has the same peculiarities as the EXPLOSIVE-BALLISTIC type except for the regime of muscular work. Here the preliminary stretch phase is sharp and clear-cut, after which there is an immediate switch to overcoming work.

Page 61 It is not difficult to conclude that during dynamic-explosive-force with 20-40% of PO, the F (t) curve is characteristically determined entirely by the starting-strength of the muscles. With a resistance of 60-80% of PO their functional characteristics are changed. As it was in the previous instance, the beginning of the F (t) curve is determined by starting-strength, however, further on it is increasingly connected with the muscles’ ability to quickly display the maximum possible strength, i.e., the acceleration-strength of muscle.

Page 62 Thus, the working-effect of an athletic movement, executed with maximal volitional tension, is determined to a greater or a lesser degree by the four qualitative special-strength abilities: absolute-strength (PO), starting-strength (Q), acceleration-strength (G) and the absolute speed of muscle contraction (Vo).

Page 65 Starting-strength (Q) and acceleration-strength (G) are weakly dependent upon each other. The general abilities to display explosive-strength (I) and acceleration-strength (G) are to a significant degree determined by an aggregate of causes. Starting-strength (Q) and the general ability to display explosive force (I) have little in common.

Page 65 …the lesser the external resistance of the movement (consequently, the faster and briefer its execution) the larger the role of such abilities as absolute speed: and especially, starting-strength. And, vice-versa, the larger the external resistance the greater the importance of acceleration and absolute-strength. In accordance with these criteria of componential abilities (which secure the working-effect of explosive force), one can arrange the following series: Vo-Q-G-PO; which can correlate concretely with the external resistance of the movement, as depicted on the abscissa in figure 30.

Page 66 It is obvious that when overcoming insignificant external resistance (20-40% of PO) man is simply unable to display his strength potential. In this instance, the impulse force producing the movement is developed chiefly by starting-strength. With a large resistance (more than 60% of PO) the impulse force securing the working movement is developed primarily by acceleration and absolute-strength. Starting-strength plays an assistive role here. Thus, in order for the working tension to reach a certain level as quickly as possible, starting-strength is the underlying mechanism crucial for the display of acceleration-strength. First, it follows that with an external resistance, starting-strength is displayed under isometric conditions of muscular tension (the greater the external resistance the larger it is expressed); and acceleration-strength is displayed in the dynamic regime; second, the higher the level to which starting-strength is developed, the faster the acceleration-strength can be realized. The latter circumstance should unconditionally be emphasized considering the limited time for the execution of a speed-strength movement in athletics.

Page 69 The regime, in which and external resistance is actively overcome after being preceded by a sharp preliminary muscular stretch, is the most effective for training explosive-strength.

Page 69-70/Bench Press Throws…I co-wrote this article prior to reading Fundamentals. Verkhoshansky figured it out 25 years ahead of me…lol. Plyometric Bench Press Training http://www.strengthcats.com/plyobenchpress.htm

Page 78/Effector vs Afferent Impulse

Page 90-91/Complex Training…same thing here…Verkhoshansky was 24 year ahead of me on this… Building Strength and Power with Complex Training http://www.strengthcats.com/complextraining.htm

taken from “The Training of the Weightlifter”, 2nd edition, by R.A. Roman

From pages 72 & 73-some interesting opinions and tidbits from a different Soviet coach, regarding specific explosive strength tests and developmental drills:

"It has already been pointed out that it is necessary to display force quickly when executing the clean (and especially in the snatch and the jerk). If one compares results in the clean and jerk with results in jumping (without weight), then one finds that there is no correlation whatsoever, between them. However, a comparison of results in the clean and jerk with the results in jumping with 50% of bodyweight reveals: that athletes who jump the highest, generally jerk more. In other words, there is a correlation (moderate) between jumping height and results in the clean and jerk. Furthermore, not all athletes who have stronger legs (higher results in the back squat), have higher results in jumping with 50% of bodyweight, i.e., the correlation between the jumping and the squat is weak.

So, with two athletes of the same leg strength, the one with the higher results in jumping with 50% of bodyweight almost always cleans and jerks more weight; because he has a greater ability to quickly display strength.

In order to successfully jerk the barbell, the minimal jumping height (with 50% of bodyweight)should be: in the 75-100 kg classes for Class III lifters–44 cm, Class II–45 cm, Class I–46 cm, CMS–47 cm, MS–48 cm, MSIC–50 cm, world record holders–51 cm; for athletes in the lighter and heavier classes–approximately 2 cm lower.

For example, David Rigert (90-100 kg class) jumped 59 cm with 50% of bodyweight; Pavel Kuznyetsov (100 kg) --62 cm; Yuri Vardanyan (82.5 kg)-- 65 cm."

Very interesting. Roman goes on to discuss depth jumping and vertical jumps with a barbell on the shoulders as two primary special means to develop explosive strength. As we have talked about the depth jumps before, I’ll just throw in what he has to say about the jumps w/ barbell:

“Vertical jumps with a barbell on the shoulders is another method of developing explosive-strength. The amount of weight should be 20% of the limit clean and jerk. The athlete does approximately 12-18 jumps for a workout; 3-6 jumps per set. Jumps with a barbell can be done 2-3 times per week. If depth jumps are employed, barbell jumps are not included.”


yeah it’s weightlifting but you will find it useful if your into the whole Russian training thing.

Thanks guys,
Thats a great help CoolColJ.
Appreciate the help before I splash the do$h.

Renegade Training for Football - Davies

*Have it, don’t recommend it. Mostly exercise descriptions (some of them are innovative (or just plain weird) but nothing particularly compelling.

Science and Practice of Strength Training Zatsiorsky

*Have it, recommended.

Supertraining 2003 sixth edition - Siff

*Have it, recommended. Lots of raw data on studies, not much as far as recommendations. Siff pretty much leaves you to draw your own conlcusions. Better from a theoretical basis than practical application.

Modern Trends in Strength Training - Poliquin

*Don’t have it.

Fundamentals of Special Strength Training in Sport - Verkhoshansky

*Have it, recommended.

Program and Organization of Training - Verkhoshansky

*Have it, recommended. But more traditional in its approach.

Science of Sports Training - Kurz

*Have it, borderline. Good info, but nothing that particularly distinguishes it.

Secrets of Soviet Sports Fitness and Training - Yessis

*Have it, borderline. Lots of anecdotes and touches on many aspects, but I come away feeling like I almost know enough to apply the info.

Cryotherapy in Sport Injury Management - Knight

*Don’t have it.

Sports Restoration and Massage - Siff & Yessis

*Have it, recommended. More of a practical slant than SuperTraining.

Thanks X - and everyone else -

So on your reccomenedations I just ordered …

Science and Practice of Strength Training Zatsiorsky
Supertraining 2003 sixth edition - Siff
Fundamentals of Special Strength Training in Sport - Verkhoshansky
Program and Organization of Training - Verkhoshansky
Secrets of Soviet Sports Fitness and Training - Yessis

Next to order are …
Cryotherapy in Sport Injury Management - Knight & Sports Restoration and Massage - Siff & Yessis

Ouch $$$$$$
:smiley:

[Xlr8 - Will have some free time coming up soon - 10 days until the deadline - so ordering some stuff as a self-present and will hope to be able to read a little more soon too!!!]

Good luck and enjoy reading something you want to read instead of have to read, for a change!

Just make sure you hve your highlighter out for the Supertraining…it reads like a textbook.

Thanks man
:smiley:
I was hoping to get to burn the highlighter soon !!

No23: Do you have Drechler? It’s not just a book for weightlifters. Chapters 3,5 and 6 especially are extremely useful for any athlete using weights. I have over 20 S&C books but this one is undoubtedly top of the pile, the book I reach for before any other (yes even Zatsiorsky!)

No I don’t.
Thanks I’ll see if I can get it on line.

That’s
Drechler, A.J.: The Weightlifting Encyclopedia. A is A Communication, Flushing, N.Y. 1999
??