Neither the simplicty of the protocol nor the methodology of cycling swayed me in my initial discussions with Dr. Weyand about Barry’s approach. Perhaps that’s why I was focused on choosing the ‘least likely candidate’ for improvement in meters-per-second for my “Barry Project.”
After Dr. Weyand’s '02 seminar here in Lisle, coaches who grasped the notion of ground support force as Dr. Weyand had explained the concept left the day in pursuit of what I referred to as the “Holy Grail” of ground support force: a program of strength/plyo work that would best improve the average mass specific force applied to the running surface to oppose gravity.
At the same time, miles away on the West coast, Barry was basically using the same term “Holy Grail” in relation to a protocol he had established based upon his grasp of the study.
To many, his descriptions and articles seem to sugggest that 1) this is the only way to train, 2) that no other programs would lead to similar gains, and 3) that everyone who didn’t follow the research was way off base.
Although Barry’s response to this analysis might be, “yes, yes, and yes,” the reality is that, as a result of actively pursuing these issues with the researchers themselves, he changed his whole approach to strength training relative to the 2000 JAP study, as well as subsequent research, which pointed out that greater application of mass specific force appears to be the mechanical means by which athletes achieve faster top end speeds.
Regarding discussion on the merits or disadvantages of the protocol, I’ll refer to something I heard just this morning at a learning asessment conference:
“All models are false, but some are useful.”
and
“Take what’s out there and apply it to your own situation.”
Inevitably, proponents or detractors are left with another unique obersvation from my assessment seminar:
“Are we willing to die on the hill for this battle”?
For my situation, I like the program, but then again I’m not at risk of dying on the hill. I’ll probably retire or get fired before that happens!