Nutrition & Health Myths

NEW YORK (Reuters Health) - Avoid eggs. Drink 8 glasses of water a day. Eating carbs will make you fat. Nutritional advice such as this has been touted for years – but is it accurate?

Not necessarily, according to Wendy Repovich, an exercise physiologist at Eastern Washington University in Cheyenne, Washington, who did her best to dispel several common nutrition misconceptions during an American College of Sports Medicine-sponsored health and fitness summit held recently in Dallas.

“Eating eggs will raise your cholesterol.” This myth started because egg yolks have the most concentrated amount of cholesterol in any food, Repovich told Reuters Health. However, when eaten in moderation, eggs do not contain enough cholesterol to pose health risks, she said.

“Most people avoid eggs and probably if they have any kind of cardiovascular risk their physicians tell them to avoid eggs,” Repovich said. “But really, there aren’t a whole lot of studies that show that one or two eggs a day really make a difference to cholesterol levels.”

Reuters Pictures

Editors Choice: Best pictures
from the last 24 hours.
View Slideshow

“Eating carbohydrates makes you fat” is another myth. Cutting carbs from the diet may help a person shed pounds due to water loss from a decrease in carbohydrate stores, Repovich said, but eating carbs in moderation does not directly lead to weight gain.

Here’s another myth. “Drink 8 glasses of water a day.” Repovich said people need to replace water lost through breathing, urinating, sweating each day – but that doesn’t necessarily total 64 ounces of water.

“I see an awful lot of people carrying bottled water around,” Repovich said. “I think people are still under the impression that they have to drink 8 glasses of water a day, but most people don’t realize they get water from other sources in the diet.”

And too much water can be harmful, Repovich warned, leading possibly to an imbalance in the body of sodium, a condition called hyponatremia.

It’s also a myth, Repovich said, that everyone needs vitamin supplements, although she admits to popping a multivitamin each morning. People who eat a variety of fruits, vegetables, whole grains, along with moderate amounts of a variety of low-fat dairy and protein and the right quantity of calories, probably don’t need a vitamin supplement, she said.

“But for the most part, we don’t eat the way we should so probably a simple multivitamin is good for most people,” Repovich said.

I’m not sure on this but it seems to be a good point regarding eggs. I understand that there is no real/established link between consumed dietary cholesterol and cholesterol readings in the blood.

If you want to go over ALL the nutrition and health myths, this will be the longest thread ever.

I think the question that needs to be asked should really be “is there a real link between cholesterol and heart disease?” I saw a presentation recently that showed there really was very little evidence and lowering cholesterol doesn’t work half of the time!

I think the recommended dose for egg is 2 egg yokes a week but you can have as many egg whites as you like.

I think the recommended dose for egg is 2 egg yokes a week but you can have as many egg whites as you like.[/QUOTE]

Barry Sears recommends this also in his “Zone” diet but for a different reason. As I understood it, he says eating too many yolks is bad because they contain arachidonic acid which keeps you out of the zone if too much is consumed.

I think that high levels of cholesterol in the blood stream do ultimately lead to heart disease. I"m not 100% positive but I believe that link has been established.

Depends on the type. Theres LDL (Low Density Lipoproteins) and HDL (High Density Lipoproteins). LDL attacks arterie walls and impinges blood flow where as HDL has been shown not do that, and even possibly REMOVE plaque blocking the arteries and transport it to the liver to be excreted or re-used.