do u have dorsal bone spurs(tiny bumps on top of your 1st metatarsals)? how much natural dorsiflexion do u have left in each big toe(by natural i mean when ur sitting on a chair and u dorsiflex big toe into air while foot remains grounded)?
myself i have dorsal bone spurs on both 1st metatarsals but i don’t have any pain or niggles on the great big toe joints during walking jogging skipping or sprinting, yet? however the ball of left foot cracks(loudly) every now and then when walking and left foot is grounded and in mid propulsion phase, mostly when barefoot or socks on hard floor, but now occasionally when on softer surfaces as well or in runners.
also, when dorsiflexing while laying or sitting these cracking(loud sounds occur) when i dorsiflex left big toe and now right as well. I’m guessing the cracking is a result of the phalanges coming out of alignment with the 1st metatarsals.